Immediately After a Car Accident, What Information Should You Gather at the Scene?

Monday, November 16th, 2026

If you get into a car accident caused by someone else’s negligence, you should first assess whether you or anyone else needs immediate medical attention and call 911 to report the accident. Provided you are physically capable and it’s safe to do so, you should then try to gather important evidence from the scene, such as taking photos of the vehicles and noting any nearby surveillance cameras.

Although you may not be thinking of potential litigation immediately after a car accident, this evidence could be critical later if you decide to file an injury lawsuit. You may also need some of it to file an insurance claim.

In This Article:

What Information Should You Prioritize Gathering Right After a Car Accident?  

Whether you were in a fender bender or a more serious collision, you’ll want to collect the following information after a car accident, if possible. An attorney can evaluate your specific situation and let you know whether you may have a personal injury case.

Obtain Information About the Other Driver

Your insurance company will want details about who else was involved in the accident. An attorney will also need to know who the defendants in the case should be.

  • Names and contact information: Include any passengers as well, in case their witness testimony could be valuable.
  • Insurance information: Ask for the name of the other driver’s insurance company.
  • Make, model, and license plate of the other car(s): If there were multiple cars involved in the collision, get this information for all of them, not just the car that hit you.

Capture Digital Evidence at the Car Accident Scene

Photos and videos can help demonstrate specific details about how the accident unfolded and its aftermath. If you file an injury lawsuit, this will be important for proving liability (who was responsible for causing the accident) as well as damages (the compensation owed to you).

  • Take photos or videos of the accident scene: Include your injuries, exterior damage to the vehicles, the interior of your vehicle if it was damaged, and the positioning of the vehicles before they are moved. If you have a dash cam, ensure that you save footage of the accident so it isn’t erased or overwritten.
  • Check if the other driver has a dash cam: If you hire an attorney later and share this information with them, they can send a preservation letter to the defense so that the footage on the camera is not erased or discarded, and get the dash cam footage into evidence.
  • Take note of nearby businesses with surveillance cameras: The accident may have been caught on video, but your legal team will have to act fast. Surveillance cameras typically store their footage for less than 30 days before recording over it.

Take Note of Any Car Accident Witnesses

You should be alert for anyone who can corroborate your account of what happened.

  • Neutral bystanders: The testimony of unbiased witnesses who were not involved in the accident can be particularly helpful. If possible, you should ask the names and contact information of anyone who stopped to help or saw what happened.
  • Police report: If the police arrived at the accident scene, they will fill out a report. A police report generally includes an outline of what the police think happened, statements from drivers and witnesses (when available), and what the police attribute as contributing factors to the accident, even assigning fault for the collision when there are facts that support it. You can request a copy of the police report and it can potentially be entered into evidence and play a pivotal role in the outcome of your lawsuit.

What Evidence From a Car Accident Scene Can a Lawyer Obtain? 

You should share as much information about the accident scene as you can with your lawyer, including photos, videos, and observations. They can also do their own investigation and request access to additional information. Your lawyer will use these details to corroborate your testimony.

  • Surveillance video: Lawyers may have more resources than average citizens to obtain surveillance video footage. For example, at Block O’Toole & Murphy, we will send an investigator to canvass the scene for witnesses and request surveillance footage from nearby buildings. Witnesses, local businesses, and residents with relevant information can be subpoenaed to provide testimony at trial.
  • Defendant driver’s photos and videos: An attorney can send a preservation letter instructing the defendant not to destroy any evidence they gathered, and to share it as part of the discovery
  • Taped 911 calls: They often contain verbal descriptions of the accident and the identities of vital witnesses.
  • Police bodycam footage: This can objectively show crucial details about the accident scene.

Case Study: How an Unusual Piece of Video Evidence Helped Settle a Car Accident Case

Photos and videos are especially helpful in resolving cases. For instance, Block O’Toole & Murphy once handled a case involving a multi-car pileup on the Cross Bronx Expressway. In a complex situation like this, it would be challenging to prove who was liable for causing the accident and properly allocate the insurance money among the four injured plaintiffs. Regardless, we were determined to fight for fair compensation for our client, who had the most severe injuries.

In his investigation, Associate Kristian Krober noticed an important detail in the police report, which stated that a responding officer had a video of the collision. We didn’t have much information about this video or where it came from, but Krober subpoenaed the NYPD for it.

The NYPD gave us body camera footage from the responding officer. He had reviewed dash cam footage of the crash from another car at the scene, and his body cam had captured everything in frame. The video of the accident was able to clear up questions around liability and damages.

We sent the video to the defendant’s insurance company and were able to obtain the largest settlement resulting from that accident. In this instance, a video of a video helped us negotiate a strong outcome for our client.

New York Motor Vehicle Accident Lawyers

If you’ve been in a car accident, Block O’Toole & Murphy is here to help. We’ve recovered over $2 billion for clients we represented in personal injury cases, including a $22.5 million settlement for a driver injured in a head-on collision, and a $9.75 million settlement for a tow truck driver who was violently rear-ended by a drunk driver.

For a free legal consultation, call us at 212-736-5300, or fill out our online contact form. We serve all five boroughs of New York City as well as the entirety of New York State and New Jersey.

Archives

Free Initial Case Review

Fill out our short online contact form for a FREE, immediate case review, or call us locally at 212-736-5300 today. The lawyers in our firm work on a contingency basis, so we do not collect any money unless we win your case.