Brooklyn Car Accident Lawyers
Getting into a serious car accident can be a stressful and life-altering event, with financial pressures and a long road to physical and mental recovery. If you were injured due to someone else’s negligence, Block O’Toole & Murphy will fight tirelessly on your behalf.
Our attorneys have decades of experience securing strong results for Brooklyn car accident victims, including an $8,000,000 settlement for a pedestrian struck by a tandem bus and a $4,000,000 recovery for a young girl hit by a car in Bushwick. Learn more about our track record and how we approach Brooklyn car accident cases.
Need to Know:
- The attorneys at Block O’Toole & Murphy have recovered more than $250 million in Brooklyn car accident cases, ranging from truck accidents to pedestrian accidents.
- Generally, you can file your case in a Brooklyn State Court if your accident occurred there, or if you or one of the defendants resides or has headquarters in Brooklyn. Municipal cases usually must be filed in the borough where the accident occurred.
- If you were injured in a car accident, you should reach out to an attorney for legal advice as soon as possible. A lawyer can preserve critical evidence before it’s lost and ensure you don’t miss important deadlines for your accident case.
In This Article:
- Why Choose Block O’Toole & Murphy for Your Brooklyn Car Accident Case?
- $9.5 Million Settlement for a Pedestrian Struck by a NYCTA Bus on Kings Highway
- Factors That Affect Brooklyn Car Accident Cases
- How Do Experienced Attorneys Have an Advantage in Brooklyn Car Collision Cases?
- Significant Verdicts and Settlements in Brooklyn Auto Injury Cases
Why Choose Block O’Toole & Murphy for Your Brooklyn Car Accident Case?
Stellar results. We have recovered over $2 billion for clients in serious personal injury matters. According to ALM’s VerdictSearch, since 2012, no other law firm in New York has attained more results exceeding $1 million than Block O’Toole & Murphy. This track record combined with our history of securing landmark verdicts at trial helps us negotiate strong settlements with defense attorneys and insurance adjusters.
Some of our top results in Brooklyn car accident cases include:
- $12,000,000 settlement for a five-year-old child who was severely injured when a two-car collision caused one of the vehicles to jump the sidewalk and strike him. He suffered multiple fractures, internal injuries, and artery damage requiring surgery. Our firm’s accident reconstruction engineer was able to scientifically prove that one of the vehicles was speeding at the time of the accident. The payout is expected to yield the plaintiff $71,643,000.
- $6,000,000 settlement for a man who was injured when the bus he was riding on collided with another vehicle. The impact was so heavy that the bus almost tipped over, and he ultimately required multiple surgeries for his shoulder, knees, and back. The case settled during the third week of trial.
- $4,750,000 settlement for a union transit worker who was out walking his dog when he was struck by a New York City Sanitation vehicle that ran a stop sign. He was briefly rendered unconscious and later suffered post-concussion symptoms, and required surgical procedures for his neck, back, knee, and wrist. We were able to obtain a video of the accident from a nearby building that showed he was not at fault.
Award-winning attorneys. Our lawyers are recognized within the legal community for their achievements and advocacy. Partners Stephen J. Murphy, Jeffrey A. Block, and Daniel P. O’Toole were each named Best Lawyers® Lawyer of the Year in Personal Injury – Plaintiffs for the New York Metro Area in 2022, 2023, and 2026, respectively. They were also included on Super Lawyers’ New York Top 100 list, which recognizes the 100 best attorneys across all practice areas in the region. In 2026, 15 attorneys from our firm were selected to the Super Lawyers or Rising Stars lists for the New York Metro area. Stephen J. Murphy also served as President of the Brooklyn-Manhattan Trial Lawyers Association.
Brooklyn roots. Many of our attorneys have lived in Brooklyn, which gives them an advantage in understanding how jurors might perceive a case. Several of our attorneys also started their careers as assistant district attorneys in Brooklyn and have substantial experience trying cases in Kings County Supreme Court, including Partners Stephen J. Murphy (who was once the youngest prosecutor in Brooklyn’s Homicide Bureau), S. Joseph Donahue, Scott Occhiogrosso, and Associate Aaron Fishkin.
$9.5 Million Settlement for a Pedestrian Struck by a NYCTA Bus on Kings Highway
In one case handled by Block O’Toole & Murphy, our client was a 32-year-old man who had just left a Western Union in Midwood, Brooklyn and was walking to a nearby store. While he was crossing Kings Highway at the intersection of East 18th Street, he was suddenly struck by an NYCTA bus that was making a right-hand turn.
Horrifyingly, our client was dragged under the bus until it finally came to a stop. Police and EMS responded to the scene, and he was immediately taken by ambulance to Kings County Hospital.
The Impact of Severe Bus Accident Injuries
Tragically, our client’s injuries were extensive, requiring a two-month stay at Kings County Hospital. He suffered a below-the-knee amputation of his right leg, as well as fractures of the pelvis, scapula, and clavicle, a dislocated hip, and a spinal disc herniation. He had seven operations to address these injuries, followed by prolonged physical therapy.
Our client later received a prosthetic to help improve his mobility, but he still struggled with pain that affected his ability to sit or walk for long periods of time. The accident took away his independence and affected every facet of his life. He was unable to bathe himself, work to provide for his family, or play with his children.
This was a life-altering accident that never should have happened, and our attorneys were determined to fight for the compensation this client deserved.
Obtaining Documentation Early On
One of the facts in contention with the defense was whether the plaintiff was safely crossing the street in the crosswalk, with the signal in his favor. This would help determine who was liable, or at fault, for causing the accident.
Since the accident was so serious, the New York City Transit Authority sent an investigator to the scene. During the discovery phase of the lawsuit, we demanded documentation related to this internal investigation. In his memorandum, the NYCTA investigator concluded that the bus operator had not followed safe driving practices, that the pedestrian was in the crosswalk when he was struck, and recommended that the bus driver be held accountable for the accident.
While this report was helpful, we also obtained a police report of the accident that indicated the plaintiff had crossed the street against the walk signal. We needed to do our own investigation to figure out exactly what happened.
Investigating the Bus Operator’s Claims
The bus operator called dispatch three times to report the accident, and we were able to obtain transcripts of the calls. In them, he placed the blame squarely on the plaintiff, stating that he ran out from between two parked cars into the road directly in front of the bus.
This statement was demonstratively false when compared with the physical evidence. Furthermore, when we deposed the bus operator, he stated that he never saw the plaintiff prior to the impact, directly contradicting his earlier story. His inconsistent statements quickly unraveled his attempt to appear blameless for the accident.
Investigating Statements Made by a Witness for the Defense
One witness for the defense claimed that the accident was our client’s fault, and not the bus operator’s, because she had seen him attempt to cross the street when the signal was flashing red for pedestrians. However, her version of events didn’t add up.
The plaintiff’s assertion that he was coming from the Western Union just a block away was corroborated by records and a receipt for the transaction in the sweatshirt he was wearing at the time of the accident. We therefore knew with certainty which direction the plaintiff was walking from.
The witness for the defense was very firm about seeing the plaintiff in front of one particular store. However, we had extensively canvassed the area around Kings Highway and East 18th Street, and we knew that store was in the opposite direction of where the plaintiff was walking. Since it was impossible for the plaintiff to be where this witness said he was, her credibility fell apart.
Leveraging Evidence to Negotiate a Settlement
We hired a liability expert to analyze physical evidence from the scene, and he ultimately concluded that the bus operator was negligent. By connecting with members of the community and Midwood business owners, we were also able to secure surveillance footage that showed portions of the accident, which proved that the bus operator was clearly at fault.
In the end, the evidence we collected was overwhelming, and the NYCTA agreed to settle the case for $9.5 million.
Factors That Affect Brooklyn Car Accident Cases
This borough has its own unique characteristics that can influence how car accidents unfold. Our attorneys have extensive experience litigating these types of collisions.
Car Accidents on High-Speed Roadways
Major roads in Brooklyn can be very congested, especially those connecting Brooklyn and Queens, like the Jackie Robinson Parkway, the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, and the Belt Parkway.
Additionally, many of Brooklyn’s major routes were constructed between the 19th and early 20th centuries — such as Eastern Parkway, which opened in 1874 as the world’s first parkway. Cars have gotten increasingly bigger since these historic routes were originally designed, a trend known as autobesity or car bloat.
This has many adverse effects that can contribute to accidents, like reducing vehicle capacity in lanes (which in turn worsens gridlock) and narrowing the space between lanes, which increases the likelihood of sideswipe accidents. Our firm has represented many victims of this type of accident, including a $2.5 million settlement for a man whose spine was injured when he was sideswiped by a vehicle attempting to leave a parking space in Cypress Hills.
Car Accidents in Busy Commercial Areas
Double parking is common in Brooklyn, creating extra congestion and reducing visibility for other drivers. It can be especially problematic in dense commercial areas lined with stores, such as stretches of Atlantic Avenue, Kings Highway, and 20th Avenue in Bensonhurst.
Notably, video footage of an accident is usually easier to find in these areas compared to quiet residential streets, as many stores have installed surveillance cameras. This footage can be critical evidence in a car accident case, as it objectively shows what happened. Our attorneys canvass accident sites right away to obtain video footage whenever it’s available.
Brooklyn Pedestrian Accidents
Brooklyn has the largest population of any borough. According to the New York City Department of Transportation (NYCDOT), it also has the largest share of pedestrian fatalities, at 34% of New York City’s total.
The City has extensively studied pedestrian accidents in order to plan and implement street safety upgrades, such as pedestrian refuge islands (which help people safely cross multi-lane roads), sidewalk widening, and signal timing changes. The most recent study conducted by the NYCDOT was released in 2023, identifying these stretches of Brooklyn streets with the highest concentration of pedestrian deaths and/or serious injuries:
- Malcolm X Blvd, from Broadway to Fulton St
- Utica Ave, from Fulton St to Ave S
- Rockaway Ave, from Broadway to Rockaway Parkway
Encouragingly, data shows that safety interventions do work. Between 2014 and 2021, pedestrian fatalities nationwide increased by over 50%, but declined by 10% in New York City.
Nevertheless, even one death is too many. Our attorneys are committed to fighting for justice and securing compensation on behalf of pedestrian accident victims, including a $1.75 million settlement for the heartbroken family of a woman who was tragically killed by a bus in a Sheepshead Bay crosswalk.
Commercial Vehicle Accidents
Brooklyn has many narrow, congested streets that aren’t well suited to large vehicles like 18-wheelers, which frequently pass all over the borough to deliver food and other supplies to businesses.
Sometimes, these vehicles even collide with one another. In one case handled by Block O’Toole & Murphy, our client was a delivery driver for a water bottle company who was stopped at a red light in Sunset Park when he was rear-ended by a poultry delivery truck. The impact was heavy and caused neck and back injuries to our client, who required spinal fusion surgeries after conservative treatments failed.
Although the defense claimed the impact was minor and couldn’t have caused our client’s injuries, we countered that with photos of the truck our client was driving. The impact caused visible damage to the rear of the vehicle, including steel that had been wrenched out of place, which requires a lot of force. Partners Stephen J. Murphy and Michael J. Hurwitz ultimately negotiated a $3,375,000 settlement for our client.
How Do Experienced Attorneys Have an Advantage in Brooklyn Car Collision Cases?
Our firm has decades of experience handling injury cases in Kings County courtrooms. We also have several lawyers who have previously lived and worked in Brooklyn, some of whom still live in the borough.
There are over 70 neighborhoods in Brooklyn, each with its own unique characteristics. Local familiarity is especially helpful when it comes to preparing for specific court processes, judges’ preferences, and jury selection, as well as understanding how Brooklyn residents may perceive the details of each accident case.
Understanding Potential Biases of Drivers
The Department of Urban Policy and Planning at Hunter College reports that about 45% of Brooklyn households own a vehicle, compared to just 23% of Manhattan households. Brooklyn residents are far more likely to have an understanding of the challenges around finding parking, congestion, the impact of large trucks in narrow streets, and more. Since they’re drivers themselves, they may also have strong opinions on other types of motorists on the road.
- Buses: Some people dislike bus operators due to past experiences riding the bus, or believe they don’t follow the rules of the road as they ought to.
- Motorcycles: Some people believe they drive recklessly.
- Yellow cabs: Some people have experienced taxi drivers refusing to pick them up or drop them off in certain areas, especially in Brooklyn neighborhoods that are socioeconomically disadvantaged.
It’s important for attorneys to understand the attitudes that shape these perceptions and how they could help or hurt a case that goes to trial.
Significant Verdicts and Settlements in Brooklyn Auto Injury Cases
The attorneys at Block O’Toole & Murphy have achieved many strong results for Brooklyn car accident victims, including:
- $12,000,000 settlement for a child severely injured when a two-car collision caused a vehicle to jump the sidewalk
- $9,500,000 settlement for a pedestrian struck by a bus while crossing Kings Highway
- $8,000,000 settlement for a pedestrian struck by a tandem bus
- $6,000,000 settlement for a passenger injured in a bus collision on North Conduit Boulevard at the Crescent Street intersection
- $4,750,000 settlement for a union transit worker who needed multiple surgeries after he was struck by an NYC Sanitation vehicle at a Brooklyn intersection
- $4,000,000 settlement for a 12-year-old girl hit by a car on Jefferson Avenue
- $3,375,000 settlement for a driver who was rear-ended by a truck while stopped at a red light in Sunset Park
- $3,369,066.75 verdict for a Brooklyn court clerk injured in a rear-end collision at 16th Street and Prospect Park West
- $3,500,000 settlement for a bus operator who was rear-ended by a NYC Sanitation truck in Brooklyn
- $3,250,000 settlement for a Brooklyn driver who suffered back and shoulder injuries after a head-on accident at the intersection of Avenue U and East 70th Street
- $3,000,000 settlement for a driver injured in a tractor-trailer collision at Flatbush Ave and Dean Street
- $3,000,000 settlement for a bus passenger hurt in a T‑bone collision with an NYPD emergency vehicle at the intersection of Dekalb Avenue and Tomkins Avenue
- $3,000,000 settlement for a man whose vehicle was struck by an NYC Sanitation Department snow plow on Pennsylvania Avenue
- $3,000,000 settlement for a man who required a total hip replacement after an MTA bus collision in Flatlands
- $2,800,000 settlement for a pedestrian hit by a vehicle that rolled onto the sidewalk due to a two-car collision in Clinton Hill
- $2,760,000 settlement for a front-seat passenger hit by a UPS truck on Avenue D
- $2,558,000 settlement for the family of a victim who died after an accident with a drunk driver in Brownsville
- $2,500,000 settlement for a man whose car was hit by a vehicle exiting a parking spot in Cypress Hills
- $2,500,000 settlement for a pedestrian who suffered severe injuries after a large truck ran over her leg on Foster Avenue
- $2,500,000 settlement for a woman injured in a T-bone accident with a cement mixing truck on East New York Avenue
- $2,500,000 settlement for man with herniated discs after a rear-end collision at the intersection of Gates Avenue and Broadway
- $2,500,000 settlement for woman injured in a chain rear-end collision on Bay Ridge Parkway
- $2,200,000 settlement for a 60-year-old pedestrian who was hit by an NYC Transit bus that was attempting to turn left in Flatlands
- $2,056,656 verdict for a Brooklyn teacher struck by a city bus while crossing Boerum Place at the Livingston Street intersection
- $2,000,000 settlement for driver hit by car that ran a red light on Metropolitan Avenue
- $1,975,000 settlement for a back-seat passenger injured after a moving truck ran a stop sign on Snediker Avenue
- $1,941,000 verdict for a woman injured after a driver made an illegal U-turn in Parkville
- $1,900,000 settlement for a driver hurt in Bay Ridge by a car that didn’t yield the right of way
- $1,800,000 settlement for NYPD sergeant who suffered a TBI from a crash with a speeding truck on Flatlands Avenue
- $1,750,000 settlement for the wrongful death of a pedestrian struck by a bus in Sheepshead Bay
- $1,700,000 settlement for a 51-year-old driver rear-ended on South Conduit Avenue at its intersection with Forbell Street
- $1,675,000 settlement for a Brooklyn tailor who was rear-ended when he exited the Belt Parkway at Cropsey Avenue
- $1,600,000 settlement for a bus passenger hurt in a rear-end accident in Bedford-Stuyvesant, requiring spinal fusion surgeries
- $1,600,000 settlement for a 17-year-old passenger with spinal injuries after a Brooklyn car accident
- $1,500,000 settlement for a 55-year-old car passenger struck by a city bus in Flatbush
- $1,450,000 settlement for a Brooklyn art teacher injured in a collision with a bus
- $1,410,000 settlement for a couple with serious back injuries after an accident at the intersection of Avenue L and Ocean Avenue
- $1,400,000 settlement for a passenger on a public bus that was involved in a collision on North Conduit Boulevard near Crescent Street
- $1,350,000 settlement for a pedestrian hit by a school bus on Fourth Avenue and 93rd Street
- $1,300,000 settlement for a cyclist hit by a car at the intersection of Beech Street and Richard Street
- $1,300,000 settlement for a passenger injured in a two-vehicle collision at Stanley Avenue and Fountain Avenue
- $1,275,000 settlement for a pedestrian hit by a delivery van in Bay Ridge
- $1,250,000 settlement for a driver who hurt her neck and back after hitting a pothole on Atlantic Avenue
- $1,250,000 settlement for driver rear-ended by a commercial box truck at the intersection of Fountain Avenue and Linden Boulevard
- $1,250,000 settlement for a driver with severe lower back pain after a Clarkson Avenue crash
- $1,200,000 settlement for a driver rear-ended at Ditmas Avenue and East 94th Street
- $1,075,000 settlement for a taxi passenger that was sideswiped by a limo
If you were hurt in a Brooklyn car accident, Block O’Toole & Murphy is here to help. For a free legal consultation, call us at 212-736-5300 or fill out our online contact form. We serve all five boroughs of New York City as well as the entirety of New York State and New Jersey.

