Pain and Suffering in New York Wrongful Death Lawsuits

It is never easy to handle the loss of a loved one, but it is even more difficult if that person’s death was due to someone else’s negligence. Reasonably so, the family members of someone who has died in an incident like a car accident do not want to think about how their loved one may have suffered before their death. However, if you are thinking of bringing a wrongful death case on behalf of the deceased, you can sue for various damages, one of those being pain and suffering. Although it is tough to think about, considering the extent of a victim’s pain and suffering prior to death is often necessary in order to ensure the family and loved ones of the decedent are getting the full amount of compensation they deserve.

The wrongful death lawyers at Block O'Toole & Murphy are here to help you through this difficult time. We can assist you in calculating the various damages you may be entitled to as a surviving family member in a wrongful death case in New York, including pain and suffering. Call us at 212-736-5300 to speak to an expert attorney today.

What is Pain and Suffering?

Pain and suffering refers to one of the damages the victim's family may be entitled to receive when making a wrongful death claim. It is generally measured the same way as pain and suffering damages in personal injury cases. In both personal injury and wrongful death cases, damages are often split into economic and non-economic categories. Economic damages include things like the deceased's medical bills, funeral expenses, and loss of income. These damages are typically easier to quantify.

In contrast, non-economic damages have less to do with the measurable logistics of a personal injury or wrongful death case, and more about how the injury or death affected the victim, as well as how the victim's family will be affected long-term. Pain and suffering falls into this category of damages. Specifically, in a wrongful death case, it means that the surviving family members of the deceased can claim damages for the pain and suffering that their loved one endured before their time of death, whether that was almost immediately in a car accident, or after being treated in a hospital for weeks.

Unfortunately, these kinds of damages are not easy to calculate. It is incredibly difficult to put a monetary value on the pain and suffering someone has experienced in an accident, because it does not merely constitute physical damages. It can extend to a person's mental health long after the physical injuries have healed. For example, if a person gets into a car accident, they might sustain physical injuries such as broken bones or a concussion. Although painful, those injuries will heal over time. As a consequence of these injuries, however, the accident victim might be unable to work for an extended period of time or take part in activities they enjoy. Their injuries could develop complications and lead to unforeseen issues that affect their daily life. These difficulties could lead to emotional issues as well, such as depression, anxiety, anger, and in extreme cases, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Although these kinds of damages are more difficult to calculate, they are just as deserving of compensation as physical injuries, since they also deeply affect the victim's life. This is still applicable in the case of wrongful death. Even though the victim did not survive the accident, the mental and physical pain and suffering that they experienced in the time before death can be calculated and claimed by the victim's family. That could mean weeks spent in a hospital receiving treatment before passing, or the few minutes between when the accident occurred and time of death. Both constitute pain and suffering, and although unpleasant to think about, the surviving family members deserve compensation for it.

How is Pain and Suffering Calculated?

There are two methods that are the most widely used to get an estimate for how much pain and suffering damages might be worth, although no amount that you come up with yourself is guaranteed. To calculate the exact number, you would need to speak to an experienced wrongful death attorney in order to figure out the full amount you might be able to claim. The two methods are:

  • Multiplier method
    When using this method, all of the economic damages (medical bills, funeral expenses, etc.) will be multiplied by a number that ranges from 1 to 5. The resulting figure is meant to represent the value of the victim's pain and suffering. Typically, the more severe the injuries or the longer the victim suffered before their time of death, the higher the multiplier. Again, this figure is typically a rough estimate of what could be claimed, and in no way guarantees the actual amount of damages.
  • Per diem method
    Similar to the multiplier method, the per diem method also provides a rough estimate of the pain and suffering damages that could be owed. Using this method, a "daily rate" is selected and is multiplied by the number of days that the accident and resulting injuries impacted the victim's life before they died.

You can also potentially seek compensation from the neglectful party's insurance company (a third-party claim). Insurance companies do not necessarily use the methods above to calculate damages, even though it is a way for you to get a ballpark figure. Instead, many insurance companies use computer programs and consider things like the severity of the injury and the type of medical treatment the victim received. Treatment from a medical doctor would likely be taken more seriously by insurance companies than a chiropractor, for example.

Pain and Suffering Damages in New York

Most of the information above generally applies to most wrongful death or personal injury cases, but there are a couple caveats that apply only to New York.

Mental Pain and Suffering

In New York State, families of the victim are unfortunately not entitled to compensation for their own mental pain and suffering (although they can recover some for the victim's pain and suffering). For example, if a person died in a car accident in New York, the family could only claim damages for the emotional pain and suffering the victim would have been entitled to had they lived. Family members cannot claim damages for their own emotional trauma due to the loss of their loved one. We at Block O'Toole & Murphy believe this state law is out of date; the loved ones of the victim should be able to receive compensation for the unnecessary emotional trauma they have been subjected to as a result of another party's negligence.

No Caps for Pain and Suffering Damages

New York is one of the few states that does not set limits on the amount of damages that can be claimed in a wrongful death or personal injury case. This means that the jury can award any amount that they believe will provide full compensation for the victim, within reason. In many other states, there is a fear that juries will award much more than is economically deserved to a sympathetic plaintiff. In the hope of curbing the potential for this, there is a cap set on the amount of damages that can be awarded in personal injury or wrongful death cases. Luckily, New York does not set one of these limits, allowing all victims to have a chance at getting the full amount of compensation that they deserve.

NYC Wrongful Death Lawyers Recovering Damages

Although we understand that money will never be able to replace the loved one you have lost, the wrongful death lawyers at Block O'Toole & Murphy are here to help make this difficult time easier for you. We will bring your case all the way to trial if necessary, fighting to get the maximum amount of compensation you are entitled to, so that you are able to grieve the loss of your loved one without the added stress of financial worry.

Our results speak for themselves. Below are some notable wrongful death case results:

  • $7,525,000 settlement for a family who lost their wife and mother and 7-year-old son in a heartbreaking car accident
  • $7,200,000 settlement for the family of a 25-year-old Brooklyn man who died after falling 50 feet to the bottom of an elevator shaft
  • $5,000,000 settlement for the four children of a mother who was tragically killed when she was hit by a passing garbage truck while walking on the sidewalk
  • $3,000,000 settlement for the wife and two adult children of a man who suffered severe injuries in a car accident, leading to his death
  • $2,558,000 settlement for the wife and two children of a man who died nine months after he was in a car accident and suffered a traumatic brain injury
  • $1,500,000 settlement for the parents of a man who died in a motor vehicle accident when his car slipped on black ice, caused by the state's failure to install sufficient drainage on the roadway

If you lost a loved one in New York, you may be entitled to damages for pain and suffering. Although no amount of money can replace a loved one, filing a wrongful death lawsuit in New York can help you achieve peace of mind and provide you with financial support during this challenging time.

To speak to a wrongful death attorney at Block O'Toole & Murphy, simply call 212-736-5300 or complete the FREE case review form. Our firm serves Queens, Manhattan, The Bronx, Brooklyn and all of NYC.

Related Articles