COVID-19 Notice: Block O’Toole & Murphy has returned to full, in-person operation in accordance with safety regulations put forward by New York State and CDC health officials. Our attorneys continue to provide quality legal representation and are available to discuss your case in person, over the phone, email, or video. Read more from our partners.

Close Menu  X

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Verdicts & Settlements
  4.  » $1,700,000 for Iron Worker Injured in Car Crash

$1,700,000 Settlement for Driver Who Had Right of Way at a Four-Way Intersection


Supreme Kings


At the time of the accident, Plaintiff was a 29-year-old iron worker.


Plaintiff was driving his car when he approached a four-way intersection normally controlled on each way by stop signs. On the day of the accident, the stop sign controlling the flow of traffic coming from Defendant’s way was damaged and downed. It was undisputed that Plaintiff had arrived at the intersection prior to Defendant, giving him the “right of way” to proceed through the intersection once traffic so permitted. Plaintiff entered the intersection after lawfully stopping and observing his surroundings. Plaintiff noticed Defendant’s car approaching the intersection to his right, however, since Plaintiff was under the impression that the driver would stop, he proceeded through the intersection as one typically would. Defendant, on the other hand, acted recklessly by failing to notice the downed sign and/or any other observable indications that he was supposed to stop prior to entering the intersection.

There were two issues of liability at the center of this case. The first involved assessing Defendant’s liability for the accident. Defendant had not been exercising proper and reasonable care in the operation of his car when he proceeded into an intersection without slowing, stopping, or observing what was available to observe.

The second and more significant issue, with respect to the legacy of this case, was vicarious liability imposed upon the Codefendant as a result of their technical ownership of the car. Under the doctrine of vicarious liability in New York State, a vehicle owner can be held liable in an unlimited capacity for the negligent operation of said vehicle absent any negligence on the part of the owner himself.

Defendant’s car was leased to him by Codefendant, an automobile dealership. The policy insuring the Codefendant dealer offered substantially more coverage than that provided by the Defendant driver. This allowed Plaintiff to recover a sum much greater than would have been possible had vicarious liability not implicated Codefendant dealership in the negligent operation of its vehicle leading up to the accident.


As a result of the accident, Plaintiff suffered both an exacerbation and activation of lumbar and sacral discs that he had herniated in a prior automobile accident. Plaintiff’s L-3 through S-1 vertebral discs were previously injured in an auto accident seven years prior. The recent auto accident both activated and exacerbated Plaintiff’s herniated back to the extent that he required medical treatment and eventual surgery. Plaintiff treated for two weeks after the second accident and then resumed treatment nine months thereafter. Plaintiff resumed working as an ironworker, however, his injuries were so severe that they impeded his ability to work. Plaintiff had no other choice to deal with the daily pain but to resort to lumbar surgery.


This case settled prior to trial with the plaintiff recovering in the amount of $1.7 Million.


This case was handled by Jeffrey A. Block, Esq.

Free Consultation with a
Block O'Toole & Murphy Attorney

For a consultation with one of our injury attorneys, please call 212-736-5300 or fill out the online form below.